Student Loan Repayment Plan Comparison Calculator

Compare Standard, Graduated, Extended and income-driven repayment side by side: starting payment, total interest, payoff time and forgiveness.

The repayment plan you choose changes what you pay every month and what you pay in total — by thousands. This tool simulates four plan shapes on your actual balance and rate: the 10-year Standard plan, a Graduated plan whose payments step up as your career grows, a 25-year Extended plan, and an income-driven estimate at 10% of discretionary income. Compare starting payments, total interest, time to payoff and any balance projected to be forgiven.

How this calculator works

Standard and Extended use level amortization over 120 and 300 months. Graduated solves for a starting payment that amortizes in 120 months while rising 7.5% every 24 months. The income-driven estimate sets each year’s payment at 10% of (Income − 150% of the official 2026 HHS poverty guideline for your household size and region), growing with your income, over up to 240 payments, with the remaining balance shown as estimated forgiveness.

Key benefits

Assumptions & exclusions

Frequently asked questions

Are these the official federal repayment plan figures?

No. They are educational simulations of each plan’s structure. Official payment amounts are calculated by your loan servicer from your actual loans, family size, income documentation and the plan rules in force. Plan names, terms and availability also change with regulation and legislation — verify on StudentAid.gov.

Why does the Extended plan cost so much more interest?

Stretching payments over 25 years instead of 10 means the balance declines far more slowly, so interest accrues on a larger balance for much longer. The monthly relief is real, but on a typical balance the extra interest can reach five figures.

How does the income-driven estimate work?

It follows the widely used structure of 10% of discretionary income, where discretionary income is your income above 150% of the federal poverty guideline for your household (taken from the official 2026 HHS table for the household size and region you select). Payments are recalculated as income grows in the model, and any balance left after 240 payments is shown as estimated forgiveness.

Is forgiven loan debt taxable?

Forgiveness through PSLF is excluded from federal income tax. Forgiveness at the end of an income-driven plan has been treated differently at different times and the rules have changed repeatedly; do not plan around a specific tax outcome without checking current IRS guidance.

Can I change repayment plans later?

Federal borrowers can generally switch repayment plans, and payments already made may count differently under a new plan. Consolidation resets some counters and has its own trade-offs. Treat this comparison as a starting point and confirm the consequences with your servicer before switching.

What happens to my income-driven payment if my income falls?

Income-driven payments are recalculated from your documented income, so a genuine drop generally lowers the payment at the next recalculation, and you can usually request an earlier one after a job loss or pay cut. In this simulation, lowering the income inputs shows the effect: smaller payments, more interest, and a larger balance potentially remaining.

Formula-Based Calculator · By QalcTools Editorial Team. Formulas tested against independent reference values · Content reviewed November 2026 by the QalcTools Editorial Team.

Methodology note: Month-by-month simulation of Standard, Graduated, Extended and income-driven repayment structures as described on StudentAid.gov.

Related calculators

Category: College & Education Calculators

About this calculator

The same student loan can cost strikingly different amounts depending on the shape of the repayment plan wrapped around it: level payments over ten years, payments that start low and step up, a twenty-five-year stretch, or payments tied to your income. This calculator simulates all four shapes on your actual balance and rate, so the trade-offs stop being abstract. You see each plan’s starting payment, the total interest it produces, how long it runs, and — for the income-driven estimate — whether a balance remains at the end to be shown as estimated forgiveness. It is built for the borrower choosing a plan, or reconsidering one, who wants the full cost of a lower monthly payment stated in dollars before committing to it.

How it works

Enter your balance, your interest rate, your annual income, your household size and region — which set the official poverty guideline the income-driven estimate uses — and the rate at which you expect your income to grow. The Standard shape amortizes the loan levelly over 120 months and the Extended shape over 300. The Graduated shape solves for a starting payment that still retires the loan in 120 months while rising in steps. The income-driven estimate recalculates the payment every year as 10% of your income above 150% of the poverty guideline, simulates up to 240 payments, and shows any balance left at the end as estimated forgiveness. Every plan is simulated month by month with interest accruing on the running balance.

The formula, explained

Standard payment = Balance × i ÷ (1 − (1 + i)^−120); Extended uses 300 months; Graduated starts lower and rises 7.5% every 24 months over 120 months; Income-driven payment = 10% × max(0, Income − 150% × Poverty guideline) ÷ 12

The engine caps the rate at 100 percent and simulates every plan month by month: interest accrues on the running balance, the plan’s payment for that month is applied but never more than the balance plus interest, and the run stops at payoff or at the plan’s month cap. Standard and Extended payments come from the level amortization formula over 120 and 300 months. For Graduated, the engine discounts the stepped payment stream — rising 7.5% every 24 months — back to the balance to solve for the exact starting payment, then simulates those steps. For the income-driven shape, the payment is recomputed at the start of each year from income grown at your entered rate, using the poverty guideline passed in for your household, and the simulation runs 240 months with any surviving balance recorded as forgiven. Reported payments are rounded to cents and totals to cents as simulated.

Inputs and variables

VariableMeaningExample
Loan BalanceThe total you owe across the loans being compared. All four plan shapes are simulated on this same balance, which is what makes the comparison honest.$45,000
Interest RateThe annual rate applied to the balance in every plan. It sets the monthly interest charge that each plan’s early payments must first overcome.6%
Annual IncomeYour current yearly income, used only by the income-driven estimate to set its starting payment. The other three plans ignore income entirely.$52,000
Household Size and RegionThese select the official 2026 HHS poverty guideline applied in the income-driven estimate. A larger household raises the guideline and lowers the income-driven payment.Household of 1, contiguous states — $15,960 guideline
Income Growth RateHow fast your income is assumed to rise each year. It lifts the income-driven payment over time and shortens or lengthens that plan’s path to payoff.3% per year

Worked example

A borrower owes $45,000 at 6%, earns $52,000 with income growing 3% a year, and is a household of one in the contiguous states, so the 2026 poverty guideline applied is $15,960.

  1. Standard: the level payment over 120 months is $499.59, retiring the loan in 10 years with $14,951.07 of total interest.
  2. Graduated: solving for the stepped stream gives a starting payment of $437.55, rising 7.5% every two years; it also finishes in 120 months but costs $15,995.09 of interest — about $1,044 more for the gentler start.
  3. Extended: stretching the level payment over 300 months drops it to $289.94, but total interest climbs to $41,980.69 — roughly $27,030 more than Standard.
  4. Income-driven estimate: discretionary income is $52,000 − 150% × $15,960 = $28,060, so the starting payment is 10% of that divided by 12 = $233.83.
  5. As income grows 3% a year the income-driven payment rises with it, and the loan is retired in 219 months with $34,818.60 of interest and nothing left to forgive.

Standard: $499.59 a month, $14,951 interest, 120 months. Graduated: starts at $437.55, $15,995 interest. Extended: $289.94 a month, $41,981 interest, 300 months. Income-driven: starts at $233.83, pays off in 219 months with $34,819 interest and $0 forgiven.

The four shapes are four different bargains with time. Extended buys the lowest fixed payment at a severe interest price — nearly triple the Standard plan’s interest — while Graduated buys a modestly easier start for about a thousand dollars. The income-driven estimate is the subtlest: it starts lowest of all, yet because the payment grows with income it retires this loan in about eighteen years with no forgiveness at all, landing between Standard and Extended on interest. Whether that path suits a borrower depends on income stability and other goals, but the comparison makes clear that a low starting payment and eventual forgiveness are not the same thing.

Understanding your results

Total interest is the column that disciplines the monthly-payment instinct. Every plan here repays the same $45,000 of principal; the differences — from about $14,951 to about $41,981 — are purely the price of time. A plan that halves your payment by stretching the term does not halve your cost; it rents you cash flow at a price this page states exactly, and the right question is whether your budget genuinely needs that rental or merely prefers it.

The income-driven result deserves a careful read because it is an estimate with moving parts. Its payment is recalculated from your income every year in the simulation, so its outcome hinges on the income path you assume: steady growth retired this loan with nothing forgiven, while flat income would leave a balance at the 240-payment limit to appear as estimated forgiveness — with correspondingly more interest paid along the way. Run it at a cautious growth rate as well as an optimistic one before treating either outcome as your plan.

Assumptions and limitations

These are educational simulations of four plan structures, not servicer calculations: actual federal plan payments are computed from your individual loans, documented income and household details under the rules in force, and plan names, terms and availability change over time. The income-driven shape is deliberately simplified — a flat 10% of discretionary income against 150% of the poverty guideline — while real plans differ in their percentages, thresholds, caps and treatment of different loan types. The simulation also applies a single rate to one combined balance, accrues interest monthly without separate capitalization events, and does not model taxes on any forgiven amount. Confirm your actual options and figures with your servicer and the official federal student aid sources.

Common mistakes to avoid

Sources

Related guides