COBRA vs Marketplace Calculator

Compare the true total cost of keeping COBRA against a Marketplace plan for the months you need coverage between jobs or after a life change.

COBRA lets you keep your employer plan but at the full premium your employer used to subsidize; a Marketplace plan may cost less per month but reset your deductible and change your network. Enter both monthly premiums and what you realistically expect to pay out of pocket under each, for the exact number of months you need coverage, and compare totals — not just premiums.

How this calculator works

COBRA Total = Quoted COBRA Monthly Premium × Months Needed + Expected COBRA Out-of-Pocket. Marketplace Total = Marketplace Monthly Premium × Months Needed + Expected Marketplace Out-of-Pocket. The cheaper total, and the difference, are reported for the bridge period entered.

Key benefits

Assumptions & exclusions

Frequently asked questions

Why is COBRA so expensive?

While employed, your employer typically pays a large share of the premium invisibly. COBRA charges you the entire premium — both shares — and the plan administrator may add up to 2% for administration, as federal COBRA rules allow. The coverage is the same; the subsidy is gone.

How long does COBRA last?

Generally up to 18 months after a qualifying event such as leaving a job, with extensions in specific situations. You usually have 60 days to elect it, and coverage can be retroactive to the date you lost your employer coverage if you elect and pay in time.

What do I lose by switching to a Marketplace plan mid-year?

Progress toward your old deductible and out-of-pocket maximum does not transfer. If you have already spent heavily toward your employer plan’s deductible, staying on COBRA for the rest of the year can be cheaper overall despite the higher premium — the out-of-pocket inputs in this tool exist to capture exactly that.

Can I get subsidies on a Marketplace plan?

Premium tax credits depend on your household income for the year and are reconciled on your tax return. If you expect a low-income year after a job change, a subsidized Marketplace premium can change this comparison dramatically — enter the subsidized premium you are quoted on HealthCare.gov.

Is COBRA ever clearly the better choice?

Yes: when you have already met your deductible, have ongoing treatment with in-network providers you cannot replace, or need coverage for only a month or two before a new employer plan starts. It is a bridge product, and priced like one.

What happens if I miss the COBRA election deadline?

Missing the election window generally means the option is gone: you cannot revive COBRA later simply because you changed your mind. Your fallback is usually a Marketplace plan during a special enrollment period, which also runs on its own deadline, or coverage through a new employer. Mark both dates as soon as you receive the election notice.

Formula-Based Calculator · By QalcTools Editorial Team. Formulas tested against independent reference values · Content reviewed November 2026 by the QalcTools Editorial Team.

Methodology note: Total-cost comparison over a defined coverage bridge period, per DOL COBRA continuation guidance and HealthCare.gov plan comparison structure.

Related calculators

About this calculator

Losing employer coverage leaves you with two very different bridges: keep the plan you know through COBRA at its full, unsubsidized price, or switch to a Marketplace plan that is usually cheaper per month but starts your deductible and network from zero. Comparing the two premiums alone picks the wrong winner surprisingly often. This calculator compares what each option costs in total over the exact number of months you need coverage — premiums plus the out-of-pocket spending you realistically expect under each plan. It is built for the weeks after a job change or another qualifying life event, when the election deadline is close and the difference is measured in real money.

How it works

Enter the monthly COBRA premium you were quoted, the monthly premium of the Marketplace plan you are considering, and how many months of coverage you need. Then estimate your out-of-pocket costs under each option separately — this is where the comparison is usually decided, because spending you have already counted toward your employer plan’s deductible counts for nothing on a new plan. The tool multiplies each premium by the months needed, adds that option’s expected out-of-pocket total, and reports both totals, the cheaper option, the savings between them, and the plain monthly premium difference so you can see how much of the answer comes from premiums and how much from out-of-pocket costs.

The formula, explained

COBRA total = COBRA monthly premium × Months + Expected COBRA out-of-pocket; Marketplace total = Marketplace monthly premium × Months + Expected Marketplace out-of-pocket; Savings = Larger total − Smaller total

The engine floors the months needed at one and rounds it to a whole number, then computes each option’s total exactly as the formula states: the monthly premium, floored at zero, multiplied by the months, plus the expected out-of-pocket figure for that option, also floored at zero. It takes the absolute difference between the two totals as the savings and names the cheaper option, reporting a tie as equal. Separately, it reports the absolute difference between the two monthly premiums. Nothing else enters the calculation — no subsidy estimate, no deductible modeling — because both premiums and both out-of-pocket figures are your own inputs from real quotes and your own spending expectations.

Inputs and variables

VariableMeaningExample
COBRA Monthly PremiumThe full premium quoted by your plan administrator, which typically combines the employee and employer shares and may include a small administration charge. Use the quoted figure, not your old paycheck deduction.$750 per month
Expected COBRA Out-of-PocketWhat you expect to pay toward care under the employer plan during the bridge months, crediting any deductible progress you have already made this year.$800 over 6 months
Marketplace Monthly PremiumThe monthly premium of the Marketplace plan you would actually enroll in, after any premium tax credit you have been quoted, since that is the price you will pay.$420 per month
Expected Marketplace Out-of-PocketWhat you expect to pay under the new plan, remembering that its deductible starts from zero and its network and drug coverage may differ from your current plan.$1,800 over 6 months
Months of Coverage NeededThe length of the gap you are bridging — until a new employer plan starts, Medicare begins, or another coverage source takes over. Short and long gaps can produce opposite answers.6 months

Worked example

A worker between jobs needs 6 months of coverage. COBRA is quoted at $750 a month with $800 of expected out-of-pocket costs, because the year’s deductible is nearly met; a Marketplace plan costs $420 a month but restarts the deductible, with $1,800 of expected out-of-pocket costs.

  1. COBRA total: $750 × 6 months = $4,500 of premiums, plus $800 out of pocket = $5,300.
  2. Marketplace total: $420 × 6 months = $2,520 of premiums, plus $1,800 out of pocket = $4,320.
  3. The Marketplace option is cheaper overall by $5,300 − $4,320 = $980, even though its out-of-pocket costs are $1,000 higher.
  4. The premium gap alone is $330 a month, worth $1,980 over six months — just enough to outweigh the $1,000 deductible-reset penalty in this case.

Over 6 months, COBRA totals $5,300 and the Marketplace plan totals $4,320, so the Marketplace plan is cheaper by $980 despite higher out-of-pocket costs.

This example shows why both halves of the input matter. On premiums alone the Marketplace plan wins by a wide margin; on out-of-pocket costs alone COBRA wins, because a year of deductible progress is a real asset. The totals weigh the two against each other over your actual horizon. Stretch the bridge to a full year and the premium gap compounds further in the Marketplace plan’s favor; shrink it to two months, or raise the Marketplace out-of-pocket figure to reflect ongoing treatment, and COBRA can easily come out ahead. Run your own quotes at your own month count before deciding.

Understanding your results

The savings figure is only as solid as your out-of-pocket estimates, which are the softest numbers on the page. A useful discipline is to run the comparison twice: once with the care you expect in a normal stretch, and once with a heavier scenario — a planned procedure, ongoing prescriptions, a deductible fully spent early. If the cheaper option flips between the two runs, the decision is genuinely close and factors like keeping your doctors may reasonably decide it.

Pay attention to how the answer scales with the months input. Premium differences repeat every month, while the deductible reset is mostly a one-time cost, so longer bridges systematically favor the cheaper premium and shorter bridges favor keeping deductible progress. That is why a two-month gap before a new employer plan and a twelve-month gap are different decisions even with identical quotes — enter the horizon you actually face, not a generic year.

Assumptions and limitations

This is a cost comparison between two quotes you supply; it does not check whether you are eligible for either option, whether an election deadline has passed, or whether a Marketplace subsidy you expect will survive reconciliation on your tax return. It treats out-of-pocket spending as a single estimate per option, so it cannot model a specific treatment plan, a provider leaving a network, or a drug moving to a different tier. It also prices only the months you enter — coverage value after the bridge, such as a plan you would keep for the rest of the year, is outside the frame. Confirm deadlines and plan details with your plan administrator and the Marketplace before you elect.

Common mistakes to avoid

Sources