Health Insurance Cost Calculator
Compare High Deductible Health Plans (HDHP) vs PPO plans incorporating premiums, deductibles, and out-of-pocket maximums.
Comprehensive annual healthcare cost modeling tool. Compare total yearly financial commitments across High-Deductible Health Plans (HDHP) paired with Health Savings Accounts (HSA) versus traditional low-deductible PPO/Copay plans under low, moderate, and catastrophic medical expense scenarios.
How this calculator works
Total Annual Employee Cost = Annual Employee Premiums + min(Expected Medical Claims, Deductible) + (Remaining Claims * Coinsurance Rate up to Out-of-Pocket Maximum) - Employer HSA Contribution.
Key benefits
- Side-by-side total annual cost breakdown including employer subsidies
- Models coinsurance calculations accurately up to statutory Out-of-Pocket Maximums
- Factors in employer HSA seed contributions and preventive care exemptions
- Stress-tests plan selection under best-case vs worst-case catastrophic scenarios
Assumptions & exclusions
- Premiums, deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums are the figures from your own plan documents, as entered.
- Expected medical claims are a scenario you choose, not a prediction; actual claims vary widely year to year.
- Preventive care is treated as covered before the deductible, consistent with ACA rules for most plans.
Frequently asked questions
When is an HDHP plan more financially advantageous than a PPO?
An HDHP is usually more cost-effective either for very low medical users (due to massive premium savings and HSA tax breaks) or in catastrophic high-claim years if the HDHP has a lower out-of-pocket maximum than the PPO.
What expenses count toward the annual health insurance deductible?
Non-preventive office visits, diagnostic bloodwork, imaging, outpatient procedures, and hospital stays typically count toward the annual deductible.
How do I estimate my expected annual medical care?
Start from last year's explanation-of-benefits totals if you have them, then adjust for anything already planned — a surgery, a pregnancy, ongoing therapy. When in doubt, model three versions of the year: light, typical, and the out-of-pocket maximum, for each plan.
What happens after I reach the out-of-pocket maximum?
For covered, in-network care, the plan pays 100% of allowed charges for the rest of the year once your cost-sharing reaches the maximum. Premiums never count toward it, and out-of-network care is often tracked, or not credited, under separate rules.
Are copays included in this calculator's cost model?
Not separately. The model runs your total care through the deductible and coinsurance, while many real plans charge flat copays for visits or prescriptions that bypass the deductible. If your plan leans heavily on copays, your actual cost may come in below the estimate.
Why compare plans at the same level of care?
Premiums are fixed, but cost-sharing follows the care you actually use, so the cheaper plan can flip between a healthy year and a heavy year. Pricing both plans against identical care scenarios isolates the plan design as the only difference in the comparison.
Formula-Based Calculator · By QalcTools Editorial Team. Formulas tested against independent reference values · Content reviewed November 2026 by the QalcTools Editorial Team.
Methodology note: Affordable Care Act (ACA) statutory cost-sharing and actuarial metal tier guidelines.
Related calculators
About this calculator
The premium is the price of a health plan you can see; the deductible, coinsurance and out-of-pocket maximum decide the price you actually pay in a year of real medical care. This calculator adds both halves together for one plan at a time: your share of the premium after any employer subsidy, plus what a chosen amount of medical care would cost you under the plan’s deductible, coinsurance and out-of-pocket cap, minus any employer health savings account contribution. Run it twice — once for a high-deductible plan, once for a traditional plan, and at low and high care levels — and the cheaper plan for your likely year usually identifies itself. It turns open-enrollment guesswork into arithmetic.
How it works
Enter the plan’s monthly premium and your employer’s monthly subsidy toward it; the difference, times twelve, is your annual premium cost. Then describe your expected care as one dollar figure for the year’s total medical charges. The engine walks that care through the plan’s cost-sharing in order: you pay the first dollars up to the deductible, then your coinsurance percentage of the remaining charges, but never more than the out-of-pocket maximum in total. Any employer contribution to a health savings account is subtracted from your combined cost, because it is money provided to pay exactly these bills. The result shows your premium total, your out-of-pocket medical total, the combined annual cost, what the insurer paid, and whether your care reached the deductible or the out-of-pocket cap.
The formula, explained
Your medical cost = min(Care, Deductible) + min((Care − Deductible) × Coinsurance%, OOP max − Deductible); Total cost = (Premium − Subsidy) × 12 + Your medical cost − HSA contribution
- Premium — Monthly plan premium before employer subsidy ($/month)
- Deductible — Amount of care you pay in full before coinsurance begins ($/year)
- Coinsurance% — Your percentage share of charges after the deductible, until the out-of-pocket maximum (%)
- OOP max — Ceiling on your total medical cost-sharing for the year ($/year)
- Care — Total medical charges in the scenario year you are modeling ($/year)
The engine floors the premium, subsidy, deductible and care figures at zero, and treats the effective out-of-pocket maximum as at least the deductible. Your premium share is the monthly premium minus the subsidy, floored at zero, times twelve. For medical costs it charges you the lesser of your care and the deductible in full, then applies your coinsurance rate to the charges above the deductible, capped so your combined medical payments cannot exceed the out-of-pocket maximum. The employer health savings account contribution is subtracted from the sum of premiums and medical costs, with the total floored at zero. The insurer-paid figure is your care minus your medical cost share. All dollar outputs are rounded to whole dollars.
Inputs and variables
| Variable | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Plan Type (HDHP or PPO) | The label for the plan design you are modeling. The math follows the numbers you enter; the type mainly frames which premium and deductible combination you are testing. | HDHP |
| Monthly Premium | The full monthly price of the plan before your employer’s contribution. Comparing plans on this figure alone is the mistake this calculator exists to correct. | $460 |
| Employer Premium Subsidy (monthly) | What your employer pays toward the premium each month. Only the remainder comes out of your paycheck, and only that remainder enters your annual cost. | $260 |
| Annual Deductible | The care you fund yourself each year before cost-sharing starts. On a high-deductible plan this is the number your savings have to be ready for in January. | $3,300 |
| Coinsurance Percentage | Your share of charges after the deductible — 20 percent is common, meaning the plan pays 80 percent until the out-of-pocket maximum stops your exposure. | 20% |
| Out-of-Pocket Maximum | The most you can pay in medical cost-sharing in a year under this plan. It converts an unbounded medical risk into a bounded one you can compare and save against. | $6,800 |
| Expected Annual Medical Care | The scenario: total charges for the care you expect to use this year. Run a routine year and a bad year through the same plan to see its range. | $7,200 |
| HSA Employer Contribution | Seed money your employer deposits in a health savings account with a qualifying high-deductible plan. It directly offsets your combined cost in this model. | $750 |
Worked example
An employee models a high-deductible plan with a $460 monthly premium, a $260 employer subsidy, a $3,300 deductible, 20 percent coinsurance, a $6,800 out-of-pocket maximum and a $750 employer HSA contribution, in a year with $7,200 of medical care.
- Monthly premium / employer subsidy: $460 / $260
- Deductible / coinsurance: $3,300 / 20%
- Out-of-pocket maximum: $6,800
- Expected care / HSA contribution: $7,200 / $750
- Your premium share: ($460 − $260) × 12 = $2,400 for the year.
- Medical cost-sharing: the first $3,300 of care meets the deductible in full. Remaining care: $7,200 − $3,300 = $3,900, and your 20% coinsurance on it is $780.
- Your total medical cost: $3,300 + $780 = $4,080 — below the $6,800 out-of-pocket maximum, so the cap does not bind this year. The plan pays the other $3,120 of the $7,200.
- Combined annual cost: $2,400 premiums + $4,080 medical − $750 HSA contribution = $5,730.
Annual employee premiums of $2,400, out-of-pocket medical costs of $4,080, and a total annual cost of $5,730 for the year, with the insurer paying $3,120 of the $7,200 in care and the out-of-pocket maximum not reached.
The striking figure is the split: in a moderately healthy year, this employee pays $4,080 of the $7,200 in care personally, and premiums plus cost-sharing total $5,730 — more than the care itself would suggest glancing at the premium alone. That is not an argument against the plan; the same structure caps a catastrophic year at $6,800 of medical cost, and the HSA contribution softens every year. It is an argument for comparing plans on total cost at your realistic care level: rerun the identical care through the traditional plan’s lower deductible and higher premium, and the better buy for your household stops being a matter of taste.
Understanding your results
The total annual cost is the only figure that fairly compares two plans, and it must be computed at the same care level for both. A high-deductible plan wins most low-care years on premium savings and can win catastrophic years if its out-of-pocket maximum is lower, while a traditional plan tends to win the middle years of steady, moderate care. Run three scenarios per plan — a light year, your typical year, and the out-of-pocket-maximum year — and choose based on the pattern, not on any single run.
Notice which protections did and did not engage in your scenario. In the example the deductible was met but the out-of-pocket maximum never came into play, meaning the coinsurance percentage did the quiet work of pricing the year. If your typical care lands just above the deductible, small deductible differences between plans matter less than the coinsurance rate and premium gap. And keep the HSA contribution in view: it is real money that only exists with the qualifying plan, and omitting it overstates that plan’s cost by its full amount.
Assumptions and limitations
This model reduces a year of healthcare to one total care figure run through a single deductible, coinsurance rate and cap. Real plans divide care into categories with their own rules — copays that bypass the deductible, separate drug tiers, per-person deductibles inside family coverage, and services that are not covered at all — and negotiated prices differ from billed charges. Premiums are treated as level all year, and the employer HSA contribution is credited in full against this year’s costs even though unused HSA money can roll forward. The scenario approach still ranks plans usefully, but confirm the winning plan’s details in its official summary of benefits before enrolling, especially for any medication or treatment you know you will need.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Choosing a plan by premium alone. The example’s modest premium coexists with $4,080 of cost-sharing in an ordinary year. Total cost — premiums plus what your expected care costs you — is the comparison that matches your bank account.
- Running only one care scenario. A plan that wins a healthy year can lose the year you need surgery. Model a light year, a typical year and a maximum year for each plan before the enrollment deadline decides for you.
- Forgetting the employer HSA contribution. Seed money of $750 in the example directly reduces the high-deductible plan’s total. Leaving it out systematically biases the comparison against the plan that offers it.
- Assuming the deductible is the worst case. After the deductible, coinsurance continues until the out-of-pocket maximum — $3,500 beyond the deductible in the example. The maximum, not the deductible, is your true worst-case medical exposure.
- Ignoring whether your providers and drugs are covered. A plan can win every cost scenario here and still be wrong if your doctors are out of network or a regular medication sits on a punitive tier. Verify coverage specifics alongside the arithmetic.