Rent vs. Buy Calculator

Compare the true long-term financial net worth impact of buying a home versus renting and investing the difference.

Buying is not always financially superior to renting. This comprehensive calculator models the complete equation: home appreciation, mortgage interest, property taxes, maintenance costs (1-2% annually), and buying/selling closing costs versus renting with down payment invested in index funds.

How this calculator works

Computes cumulative net worth after N years between buying (equity - costs + appreciation) and renting (investment portfolio value from saved down payment + monthly cost delta).

Key benefits

Assumptions & exclusions

Frequently asked questions

What is the average break-even horizon when buying a home?

Due to upfront closing costs (2-5%) and future selling fees (5-6%), buying generally takes at least 4 to 7 years to become financially superior to renting.

What monthly figure should I compare with rent?

Compare rent with the full ownership payment — principal and interest plus property taxes, homeowners insurance and mortgage insurance if it applies — not with the loan payment alone. Taxes and insurance alone can add several hundred dollars a month.

Why do early mortgage payments build so little equity?

Amortization front-loads interest: on a long-term loan, most of each early payment covers interest on the still-large balance, and only a small slice reduces principal. The balance schedule on this page shows how slowly the amount owed falls in the first years.

Does renting mean throwing money away?

Rent buys housing and flexibility, and it avoids interest, taxes, insurance and maintenance costs that owners pay. For short stays or unsettled plans, renting is often the cheaper option in total, which is exactly what this comparison is designed to test.

What costs of buying are not in the monthly payment?

Closing costs at purchase, ongoing maintenance and repairs, and selling costs when you leave. None of these appear in the monthly figure, and all of them matter most when the stay is short.

How does my expected stay change the answer?

The longer you stay, the more principal each payment retires and the more years the upfront buying costs are spread across. A household likely to move within three years usually needs an unusually good purchase price for buying to beat renting.

Formula-Based Calculator · By QalcTools Editorial Team. Formulas tested against independent reference values · Content reviewed November 2026 by the QalcTools Editorial Team.

Methodology note: Discounted cash flow (DCF) comparative real estate economics model.

Related calculators

Category: Mortgage & Housing Calculators

About this calculator

Rent or buy is rarely settled by the monthly payment alone, but the payment is where any honest comparison starts. This calculator builds the full monthly cost of owning a specific home — loan principal and interest, property taxes, homeowners insurance and mortgage insurance when it applies — so you can hold it up against the rent on a comparable place. It is designed for the household standing between a lease renewal and a purchase offer: enter the price, your down payment, the rate and the term, and you get the ownership figure, the lifetime interest on the loan, and a year-by-year balance you can use to judge how long you would need to stay.

How it works

The tool prices the buying side of the decision with the standard mortgage engine. Your down payment comes off the price to set the loan amount, the payment is computed with the amortization formula at your rate and term, and then ownership costs are layered on: property tax as a yearly rate on the price divided by twelve, insurance divided by twelve, and estimated mortgage insurance when the down payment is under 20 percent. The result is one monthly ownership total to compare with rent, plus the total interest and a schedule showing how slowly the balance falls in the early years — the years when buying is most vulnerable to a move.

The formula, explained

Monthly ownership cost = M + (Price × Tax% ÷ 12) + (Insurance ÷ 12) + PMI, with M = P × i(1 + i)^n ÷ ((1 + i)^n − 1)

The engine subtracts the down payment from the price, caps the rate at 100 percent and the term at 1,200 months, and applies the annuity formula (or loan divided by months at a 0 percent rate). It then runs a month-by-month amortization — interest on the running balance, the remainder of the payment to principal — to produce lifetime interest and the yearly balance schedule. Monthly tax is the price times your tax rate divided by 12, insurance is the annual premium divided by 12, and mortgage insurance, when the down payment is under 20 percent, is estimated at 0.70 percent of the loan per year divided by 12. Displayed figures are rounded to whole dollars.

Inputs and variables

VariableMeaningExample
Home Purchase PriceThe price of the home you are considering. It drives the loan, the tax estimate and the size of the commitment you are comparing with rent.$380,000
Down PaymentCash you would pay upfront instead of keeping it available while renting. At 20 percent or more, the estimate carries no mortgage insurance charge.$76,000 (20%)
Interest Rate (APR %)The fixed rate on the purchase loan. It sets both the monthly payment and the lifetime interest that renting avoids entirely.6.75%
Loan TermThe repayment horizon, typically 30 years. A shorter term raises the monthly ownership cost but builds the balance down far faster.30 years
Property Tax RateAnnual tax as a percentage of the home price, converted to a monthly amount. Renters pay no direct equivalent, so it widens the ownership side of the comparison.1.1% per year
Homeowners InsuranceThe annual premium for insuring the property, divided by twelve. Renters insurance is far cheaper, another quiet ownership cost.$1,600 per year

Worked example

A household renting at $1,900 a month considers buying a $380,000 home with 20 percent down at 6.75 percent for 30 years, with a 1.1 percent tax rate and $1,600 a year of insurance.

  1. Loan amount: $380,000 − $76,000 = $304,000. Principal and interest at 6.75% over 360 payments: $1,972 per month.
  2. Ownership add-ons: tax $380,000 × 1.1% ÷ 12 = $348 per month; insurance $1,600 ÷ 12 = $133 per month. No mortgage insurance at 20% down.
  3. Total monthly ownership cost: $1,972 + $348 + $133 = $2,453 — about $553 more each month than the $1,900 rent.
  4. Balance check: after 5 years the schedule shows $285,382 still owed, so only $18,618 of principal has been repaid while about $99,686 of interest has been paid in that span.
  5. Over the full term the loan accrues $405,826 of interest, for $709,826 of total principal-and-interest payments.

Monthly ownership cost of $2,453 versus $1,900 rent, on a $304,000 loan with $405,826 of lifetime interest; after 5 years the balance is still $285,382.

On cash flow alone, renting wins this comparison by about $553 a month — before counting maintenance, which owners also pay. Buying’s case rests on what the monthly figure cannot show: the $18,618 of principal repaid in five years, any price appreciation, and protection from future rent increases. That case strengthens the longer the household stays, because early payments are mostly interest. A move within a few years makes the renter’s flexibility worth a great deal, which is why the balance schedule matters as much as the payment.

Understanding your results

Treat the total monthly payment as the true rent-equivalent of owning, not the loan payment alone. In the example, taxes and insurance add $481 a month that a renter never sees as separate bills, and with a smaller down payment mortgage insurance would add more. If that total is far above rent for a comparable home, buying needs a long stay and real appreciation to catch up; if it is close to rent, ownership starts competing much sooner.

The balance schedule is your stay-length test. Because early payments are mostly interest, a buyer who sells in year three has repaid very little principal yet has paid closing costs to buy and will pay selling costs to leave. The longer the horizon in the schedule, the more principal each payment retires and the more of the upfront costs get spread across years of housing. Match the schedule to the shortest stay you can realistically imagine, not the longest.

Assumptions and limitations

This page prices the ownership side with a fixed-rate mortgage model; it does not simulate rent increases, home price appreciation, investment returns on cash you keep while renting, maintenance and repairs, or the closing costs of buying and selling, all of which belong in a full rent-versus-buy analysis. Taxes and insurance are entered as level estimates and will change over a long ownership. The mortgage insurance figure, when it appears, is a flat estimate rather than a quoted premium. Use the ownership total and balance schedule here as the factual half of the comparison, then weigh them against your expected stay, local rent trends and the value you place on flexibility.

Common mistakes to avoid

Sources

Related guides