New vs Used Car Calculator
Compare the financial trade-offs between purchasing a brand-new car versus a 3-year-old certified pre-owned vehicle.
A brand-new car loses 20% of its value in year one, but a 3-year-old used car may have higher financing interest rates and out-of-warranty maintenance. Compare purchase prices, depreciation loss, loan interest, insurance, and maintenance costs to see your true 5-year savings.
How this calculator works
Total 5-Year Cost = 5-Year Vehicle Depreciation + Total Financing Interest Paid + 5-Year Insurance Premiums + 5-Year Maintenance and Repairs. Net Savings = New Vehicle 5-Year TCO – Used Vehicle 5-Year TCO.
Key benefits
- Shows the dramatic difference in first-year depreciation absorption
- Incorporates differences in insurance premiums between new and older models
- Detailed 5-year total financial breakdown
- Actionable verdict on price-to-reliability value
Assumptions & exclusions
- Used car assumed to be 3 years old with standard mileage (36,000 miles)
- Used car loan rates historically trend 1.5% to 2.5% higher than new car promotional rates
- Used car out-of-pocket maintenance estimated higher due to expiring factory warranties
Frequently asked questions
How much does a new car depreciate in the first 3 years?
On average, a new car loses about 20% of its value in the first year and approximately 15% each in years two and three. By year three, the vehicle has lost roughly 40% to 45% of its original sticker price.
Why do used car loans have higher interest rates?
Lenders consider used car loans riskier because the collateral (the vehicle) has lower market liquidity, higher mechanical breakdown risk, and harder-to-verify vehicle condition.
How old should a used car be to get most of the savings?
Around three years old is the common sweet spot. By then the first owner has absorbed roughly the 20% first-year loss plus two years at about 15%, yet the car usually has modern safety equipment and substantial service life left. This calculator's fixed depreciation shares — 50% over five years new versus 35% used — reflect exactly that head start.
Why does this calculator use different loan terms for the new and used car?
It finances the new car over 60 months and the used car over 48, reflecting how these purchases are structured — and that financing an older car over a long term risks owing money on a car near the end of its life. The term difference slightly favors the used car's interest total, worth knowing when you read the gap.
What should I check on a used car before trusting the savings?
The maintenance estimate. The used-car advantage in the example is about $12,040, but a single major out-of-warranty repair or several years of neglected servicing can consume much of it. A pre-purchase inspection by an independent mechanic, plus service records, converts the maintenance input from a guess into evidence before you commit.
Does a new car's warranty show up anywhere in this comparison?
Only indirectly, through the lower maintenance figure you would enter for the new car. The calculator does not price the warranty as a separate line, nor the value of the latest safety technology or fuel economy. If those matter to you, treat them as additions on the new car's side after the counted costs are compared.
Formula-Based Calculator · By QalcTools Editorial Team. Formulas tested against independent reference values · Content reviewed November 2026 by the QalcTools Editorial Team.
Methodology note: Kelly Blue Book (KBB) and Edmunds 5-year true cost to own data frameworks.
Related calculators
Category: Loans & Credit Calculators
About this calculator
A new car offers a warranty, the lowest rate a lender will quote, and a steep first years of depreciation. A three-year-old car offers a much lower price, a higher rate, a shorter loan, and maintenance bills the warranty no longer absorbs. This calculator puts both through the same standard auto loan engine — the new car financed over 60 months and the used car over 48, each with 15 percent down — then builds a five-year cost for each from fixed depreciation shares, the loan interest, and your insurance and maintenance estimates for both. The result is not a verdict on which car is nicer; it is the dollar size of the used car’s advantage, or the new car’s, on the costs that can actually be counted.
How it works
You enter a price and financing rate for each car, plus annual insurance and maintenance figures for both. The page finances the new car at 15 percent down over 60 months and the used car at 15 percent down over 48 months, applying your sales tax rate and fixed dealer fees of $450 on the new car and $350 on the used one. It then assembles each five-year total: depreciation is a fixed 50 percent of the new car’s price and 35 percent of the used car’s price, to which it adds the loan’s total interest and five years each of your insurance and maintenance entries. The difference between the two totals is reported as the five-year savings of one choice over the other.
The formula, explained
Five-year cost = Depreciation + Total loan interest + 5 × Insurance + 5 × Maintenance, with Depreciation = 50% of new price or 35% of used price; each loan priced by Payment = L × r(1 + r)^n ÷ ((1 + r)^n − 1)
- L — Amount financed for each car: price plus tax and fees, minus 15% down ($)
- r — Monthly interest rate for that car’s loan: APR % ÷ 100 ÷ 12 (decimal/month)
- n — Term in months: 60 for the new car, 48 for the used car in this model (months)
- Depreciation — Fixed share of price counted as five-year value loss: 50% new, 35% used ($)
The page runs the standard auto loan engine twice, once per car, with the down payment fixed at 15 percent of each price, no trade-in, your sales tax rate applied to the full price, and dealer fees fixed at $450 for the new car and $350 for the used car. The new loan runs 60 months and the used loan 48. Interest for each side comes from the engine’s month-by-month amortization simulation. Five-year depreciation is not simulated: the page simply takes 50 percent of the new price and 35 percent of the used price. Insurance and maintenance are your annual figures multiplied by five, with no inflation or age adjustment. The savings figure is the new car’s five-year total minus the used car’s. Figures are rounded to whole dollars.
Inputs and variables
| Variable | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| New Car Price | The purchase price of the new vehicle before tax and fees. It also sets the depreciation line, because half of this figure is counted as five-year value loss. | $42,000 |
| Used Car Price | The price of the used alternative, typically a few years old. Its depreciation line is 35 percent of this figure, reflecting that the steepest losses are already behind it. | $26,000 |
| New Car Interest Rate | The rate on the new car loan, often lowered by manufacturer promotions for qualified buyers. It prices a 60-month loan in this model. | 5.5% |
| Used Car Interest Rate | The rate on the used car loan, usually higher because the collateral is older and harder to value. It prices a 48-month loan here. | 7.8% |
| Annual Insurance (each car) | Yearly premiums for the new and used cars entered separately — newer cars often cost more to insure. Each figure is multiplied by five in the totals. | $1,800 new / $1,400 used |
| Annual Maintenance (each car) | Your yearly maintenance and repair estimate for each car. The used car’s figure should reflect tires, brakes and out-of-warranty repairs the new car will not need. | $400 new / $1,100 used |
| Sales Tax Rate | Your local rate, applied to the full price of each car, since neither side has a trade-in in this model. It enters each amount financed. | 6.5% |
Worked example
A buyer compares a $42,000 new car financed at 5.5 percent with a $26,000 used car at 7.8 percent, with 6.5 percent sales tax, insurance of $1,800 versus $1,400 a year, and maintenance of $400 versus $1,100 a year.
- New car: $42,000 at 5.5%, 60 months
- Used car: $26,000 at 7.8%, 48 months
- Down payments (fixed by the page): 15% of each price: $6,300 / $3,900
- Insurance / maintenance per year: $1,800 / $400 new; $1,400 / $1,100 used
- New car loan: tax is $42,000 × 6.5% = $2,730; amount financed = $42,000 + $2,730 + $450 fees − $6,300 down = $38,880. Payment: $743 a month; total interest $5,679.
- Used car loan: tax is $26,000 × 6.5% = $1,690; amount financed = $26,000 + $1,690 + $350 − $3,900 = $24,140. Payment: $587 a month over 48 months; total interest $4,039.
- Depreciation lines: new car 50% × $42,000 = $21,000; used car 35% × $26,000 = $9,100.
- New car five-year total: $21,000 depreciation + $5,679 interest + $9,000 insurance + $2,000 maintenance = $37,679.
- Used car five-year total: $9,100 + $4,039 + $7,000 insurance + $5,500 maintenance = $25,639. Difference: $37,679 − $25,639 = $12,040 in the used car’s favor.
The used car costs $25,639 over five years against $37,679 for the new car — a $12,040 advantage — even though its loan rate is higher and its maintenance estimate is nearly three times the new car’s.
Depreciation does almost all of the work: the $11,900 gap between the two depreciation lines is nearly the entire $12,040 result. The used car’s handicaps are real — $700 a year more maintenance and a rate 2.3 points higher — yet they total far less than the value the new car surrenders. What could change the answer is not the loan but the used car itself: one major out-of-warranty repair, or a used example whose condition makes the maintenance estimate optimistic, eats into the margin. The $12,040 is best read as the budget the used choice gives you for exactly those surprises.
Understanding your results
Separate the counted costs from the uncounted ones before acting on the gap. The five-year totals capture depreciation, interest, insurance and your maintenance estimates — a large, honest share of ownership cost. They do not capture fuel differences, the value of a full warranty, safety and technology differences, or how long each car will keep serving you after the five years end. A new car bought at year zero is a five-year-old car at the end of this window; the used car is eight. That remaining service life has value the totals silently assign to neither side.
Test the maintenance input, because it is the softest number on the page. The used car wins the example even at $1,100 a year, but doubling that figure to $2,200 — plausible for a neglected example with deferred work — removes $5,500 of the advantage. A pre-purchase inspection converts that guess into evidence, and its cost is trivial against a five-figure comparison. Condition, service history and mileage on the specific used car matter more than any average this page can apply.
Assumptions and limitations
The five-year depreciation figures are fixed shares of price — 50 percent for the new car and 35 percent for the used car — not a model of the specific vehicles you enter, and some models hold value far better or worse than those shares. Down payments are fixed at 15 percent and the terms at 60 and 48 months, so the page cannot test a larger down payment or equal terms. Dealer fees are fixed at $450 and $350, fuel costs are not included at all, and maintenance is whatever flat annual figure you supply, with no allowance for a single large repair. Treat the output as a framework with your numbers in it, then verify the specific used car with an inspection and both cars with real insurance quotes.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Comparing only the monthly payments. The used car’s payment is $156 lower in the example, but the five-year gap is $12,040. Payments hide depreciation, which is the largest cost difference between new and used.
- Assuming the used car’s rate settles the question. Buyers often reject used cars over a rate two points higher. Here that penalty is worth about $1,600 of extra interest — real, but small beside an $11,900 depreciation gap.
- Entering equal maintenance for both cars. A new car under warranty and a six-year-old car do not cost the same to keep. Equal figures flatter the used side; honest, separated estimates are the point of having two inputs.
- Treating the depreciation shares as a promise. Fifty and 35 percent are planning averages baked into the page. A model known for weak resale, or a used car already past its steep drop, will not follow them — check real listings for your model.
- Ignoring the age the cars reach at the end. After five years the formerly new car is five years old and the used car is about eight. If you will need to replace the older car sooner, that future purchase belongs in your thinking.