Lease vs Buy Calculator
Compare total cash outlays, equity ownership, and net financial cost of leasing versus buying a vehicle over a 3 to 6-year period.
Should you lease for lower monthly payments or buy for long-term equity? This comprehensive comparison models lease down payments, monthly lease fees, purchase financing, loan amortization, and estimated vehicle residual equity at the end of the term to declare a mathematical winner.
How this calculator works
Net Lease Cost = Lease Down Payment + (Monthly Lease Payment * Term) + Disposition Fee. Net Buying Cost = Purchase Down Payment + (Monthly Loan Payment * Comparison Term) – Residual Vehicle Equity at End of Period. Winner determined by lowest net outlay.
Key benefits
- Unbiased mathematical verdict declaring which option builds more net wealth
- Accounts for residual vehicle market equity owned at the end of the term
- Breakdown of upfront cash, monthly cash flow, and net 3-year outlay
- Clear breakdown of non-financial lifestyle pros and cons for each path
Assumptions & exclusions
- Comparison horizon aligns with the lease contract duration (typically 36 months)
- Vehicle residual equity assumes reasonable market depreciation and average condition
- Excludes potential lease excess wear-and-tear or excess mileage fees
Frequently asked questions
Why is buying usually cheaper than leasing long-term?
When you buy, you eventually pay off the loan and enjoy years of payment-free driving while holding an asset with real resale value. Continuous leasing creates a perpetual monthly payment where you never build equity.
When is leasing a vehicle advantageous?
Leasing can make sense for business owners who can deduct lease payments as an operating expense, drivers who prioritize new technology and warranty coverage every 3 years, or EV shoppers hedging against rapid battery obsolescence.
Why does this comparison only cover the lease term instead of the full loan?
Because the lease ends at that point and forces a new decision, while the purchase continues. Measuring both paths at the moment the lease expires is the fairest single snapshot: the lessee hands back the keys owning nothing, and the buyer holds equity that this calculator credits against what buying has cost so far.
What is the money factor, and why is it not shown as a percentage?
The money factor is the lease finance charge expressed as a small decimal, a format the leasing industry uses instead of an APR. Multiply it by 2,400 to get the equivalent APR percentage — 0.00208 works out to about 4.99% — which lets you compare a lease's financing cost directly with a loan's rate.
Does leasing ever win this comparison?
A lease with a strong residual value and a low money factor can cost less over three years than buying the same car, especially when the buyer would sell at the three-year mark anyway and lose the equity advantage to transaction costs. The result depends on the specific figures, which is why the comparison is worth running deal by deal.
What costs does this lease-versus-buy result leave out?
Excess mileage and wear charges at lease return, the lease disposition fee in the comparison total, insurance differences between a leased and an owned car, maintenance after a purchased car's warranty ends, and any business tax treatment. On a close result like a few hundred dollars, any one of these can be the real deciding factor.
Formula-Based Calculator · By QalcTools Editorial Team. Formulas tested against independent reference values · Content reviewed November 2026 by the QalcTools Editorial Team.
Methodology note: National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) equity lifecycle analysis.
Related calculators
Category: Loans & Credit Calculators
About this calculator
Leasing advertises a lower monthly payment; buying advertises ownership. This calculator forces the two onto the same clock — the lease term, usually 36 months — and asks what each path really costs over that window. The lease side is priced with the standard lease engine from the capitalized cost, residual value and money factor you enter. The buying side runs the same vehicle through a standard auto loan, counts what you pay over the comparison months, then credits you with the equity you would hold at the end: the car’s expected value minus the loan balance still owed. Whichever path leaves you less out of pocket after that credit is declared the financial winner, with the dollar gap shown.
How it works
The page first builds your lease payment from the lease inputs: residual value is the residual percentage of MSRP, the net capitalized cost is the negotiated price plus the acquisition fee minus lease down payment and trade equity, and the monthly payment combines a depreciation charge and a finance charge based on the money factor, plus sales tax. That payment feeds the comparison engine alongside the vehicle price. On the buying side, the engine computes a loan payment on the price minus your loan down payment, totals the down payment plus the payments made across the lease term, simulates the remaining balance at that date, and subtracts your equity — expected end value minus that balance — from what you paid. The lease total is simply its payment times the term plus the lease down payment.
The formula, explained
Lease payment = (Net cap cost − Residual) ÷ Term + (Net cap cost + Residual) × Money factor, plus tax; Net buy cost = Loan down + Payments over lease term − (End value − Balance remaining)
- Residual — Expected value at lease end: residual percent × MSRP, set by the lessor ($)
- Net cap cost — Negotiated price plus acquisition fee, minus lease down payment and trade equity ($)
- Money factor — Lease finance charge factor; multiply by 2,400 for the equivalent APR percent (decimal)
- Equity at end — Expected vehicle value at the comparison date minus the loan balance still owed, floored at zero ($)
The lease engine sets residual value to the residual percent of MSRP, builds net capitalized cost from the negotiated price plus acquisition fee minus down payment and trade equity, then charges depreciation as net cap cost minus residual spread over the term, and a finance fee of net cap cost plus residual times the money factor; tax is applied to that combined monthly amount. The comparison engine then takes the resulting total lease payment as a given input. It finances the vehicle price minus the loan down payment at your rate over your loan term, but evaluates cost only across the lease months: payments made plus the down payment, minus equity, where equity is the expected end value you supply minus the simulated remaining balance, floored at zero. Notably, this comparison total does not add the lease disposition fee, even though the lease engine’s own total lease cost does. All figures are rounded to whole dollars.
Inputs and variables
| Variable | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Vehicle Price (MSRP and Negotiated) | Leasing uses two prices: MSRP sets the residual value, while the negotiated price sets the capitalized cost. Buying uses the vehicle price as the amount to finance before the down payment. | $40,000 MSRP; $37,500 negotiated |
| Residual Percent | The share of MSRP the lessor projects the car will be worth at lease end. A higher residual lowers the lease payment because you finance less depreciation. | 55% of MSRP |
| Money Factor | The lease finance charge in decimal form. Multiply by 2,400 to compare it with loan APRs: 0.00208 is about 4.99 percent APR. | 0.00208 |
| Lease Down Payment | Cash paid at signing on the lease side. It reduces the capitalized cost and the payment, and it is added in full to the total lease cost in the comparison. | $3,000 |
| Loan Down Payment | Cash paid upfront on the buying side. It reduces the amount financed and is counted in the buying total, then partly returns through the equity credit. | $5,000 |
| Loan Interest Rate and Term | The buying loan is priced at this rate over this term, but only the payments falling inside the lease window are counted in the comparison. | 6.5% for 60 months |
| Expected Value at End of Lease Term | What you expect the purchased car to be worth when the lease would have ended. On this page it is set at 55 percent of the vehicle price, and it drives the equity credit. | $20,625 (55% of $37,500) |
| Sales Tax Rate and Acquisition Fee | The lease payment carries sales tax on the monthly amount in this model, and the acquisition fee is rolled into the capitalized cost rather than paid separately. | 6.5% tax; $695 fee |
Worked example
A driver compares leasing and buying a vehicle with a $40,000 MSRP negotiated to $37,500: lease at 55 percent residual, a 0.00208 money factor, $3,000 down and 6.5 percent tax over 36 months, versus buying at 6.5 percent for 60 months with $5,000 down and an expected value of $20,625 after three years.
- MSRP / negotiated price: $40,000 / $37,500
- Lease terms: 55% residual, 0.00208 money factor, $3,000 down, 36 months
- Loan terms: 6.5% for 60 months, $5,000 down
- Expected value after 36 months: $20,625
- Lease payment build: residual is 55% of $40,000 = $22,000. Net cap cost is $37,500 + $695 fee − $3,000 down = $35,195.
- Depreciation charge: ($35,195 − $22,000) ÷ 36 = $367 a month. Finance charge: ($35,195 + $22,000) × 0.00208 = $119. With 6.5% tax on the $485 base, the lease payment is $517 a month.
- Total lease cost over the comparison: $517 × 36 + $3,000 down = $21,612, after which the driver owns nothing.
- Buying: the loan is $37,500 − $5,000 = $32,500 at 6.5% over 60 months, about $636 a month. Down payment plus 36 payments totals $27,892.
- Equity credit: after 36 payments about $14,275 is still owed, so equity is $20,625 − $14,275 = $6,350. Net buying cost: $27,892 − $6,350 = $21,542.
Total lease cost of $21,612 versus a net buying cost of $21,542 after the equity credit — buying wins this comparison by just $70 over the three-year window.
A $70 gap is effectively a tie, and that is the honest answer for many three-year comparisons: over a single lease term, buying’s equity advantage is often almost exactly consumed by its higher payments and larger down payment. Buying pulls decisively ahead when the bought car is kept past the loan’s end, because the payments stop while the equity remains. Leasing’s case rests on what this math cannot price — a new car under warranty every three years and no resale hassle — so a near-tie on cost means the lifestyle factors, not the spreadsheet, should decide.
Understanding your results
The equity credit is where buying makes its case, so interrogate its inputs. It depends on the car actually being worth the expected value in three years and on the loan balance having fallen to the simulated level. A model that depreciates faster than projected, accident damage, or a longer loan term that slows principal repayment each shrink the credit — rerun the comparison with a lower end value to see how much disappointment the buying case can absorb before leasing wins.
Notice what the comparison window does. Judged at 36 months, buying looks expensive because its largest payments are concentrated in the window while its payoff — years of payment-free driving — sits outside it. That is not a flaw in the tool; it is a statement that lease-versus-buy has no answer independent of how long you keep cars. If your real pattern is keeping a vehicle eight years, the three-year window understates buying badly, and the right comparison is a second and third lease stacked against one purchase.
Assumptions and limitations
This comparison prices one lease against the first lease-length slice of one purchase, using an expected end value you supply — set here at 55 percent of the price — rather than any market forecast, so the equity credit is only as good as that guess. The comparison total for leasing does not include the disposition fee the lease engine lists separately, nor excess mileage or wear charges, which fall entirely on the lease side in real contracts. Insurance differences, maintenance after warranty expiry, tax treatment for business use, and the value of always driving a newer car are all outside the figures. Lease terms themselves — residual and money factor — are set by the lessor and are not negotiable in the way a purchase price is, which the inputs here can obscure.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Comparing the lease payment with the loan payment. The lease payment is lower partly because it never buys the car. The honest comparison is total cost over the same months, with buying credited for the equity it creates.
- Entering MSRP where the negotiated price belongs. Residual value is a percentage of MSRP, but the capitalized cost starts from the negotiated price. Mixing the two overstates what you finance on a lease.
- Trusting the expected end value. Buying wins the example by $70 on an assumed $20,625 value. If the car is really worth $19,000 in three years, leasing wins instead — test a pessimistic value before deciding.
- Putting a large down payment on the lease side. Lease down payment lowers the payment but can be lost entirely if the car is totaled early, because the lessor owns the car. The comparison counts the cash but cannot price that risk.
- Ignoring mileage and wear charges. Lease totals here exclude overage and wear fees. A driver covering 18,000 miles a year on a 10,000-mile lease can owe thousands at return, reversing a close result.