IRA Calculator
Head-to-head Traditional IRA vs. Roth IRA comparison. Test tax rate arbitrage and optimal account selection.
Compare Traditional IRA and Roth IRA side-by-side. See which account maximizes your net retirement spendable wealth based on your current tax bracket, anticipated retirement tax bracket, time horizon, and reinvestment of upfront tax savings.
How this calculator works
Traditional Net = [Contributions * FV_factor * (1 - Tax_ret)] + ReinvestedTaxSavings * FV_factor * (1 - CapGainsDrag). Roth Net = Contributions * FV_factor. If Tax_current > Tax_ret, Traditional generally wins; otherwise Roth wins.
Key benefits
- Side-by-side comparison of net spendable retirement income
- Incorporates outside reinvestment of Traditional tax deduction savings
- Identifies your personal tax bracket breakeven tipping point
- Calculates exact wealth difference over your investment horizon
Assumptions & exclusions
- Assumes constant annual return and tax rates throughout the projection period.
Frequently asked questions
Why does tax rate arbitrage determine whether Roth or Traditional is better?
If tax rates are identical at contribution and withdrawal, mathematically both accounts yield the same result. If your tax rate is higher today, Traditional saves more now. If your tax rate will be higher in retirement, Roth provides superior tax-free sheltering.
Does this calculator apply the IRA contribution limits?
No. It projects whatever annual amount you enter, at any size. The page notes the current standard limit of $7,500, or $8,600 from age 50, but checking your own contributions against the limit and the income rules for your situation remains your responsibility, since the comparison only works for amounts you can actually contribute.
What if my tax rate is the same now and in retirement?
With equal rates, neither account has a bracket advantage, and the two sides land close together. In this model the Traditional side can still edge ahead slightly because its upfront tax saving is invested and only lightly taxed, which is a modeling assumption worth noticing rather than a rule of real life.
What is the reinvested tax savings amount in the Traditional result?
Each year, a deductible Traditional contribution saves tax equal to the contribution times your current rate. This model assumes you invest that saving in a taxable account, grows it at the same return, and reduces it by a flat 7.5 percent for tax drag before adding it to the Traditional total.
Can I split my contributions between a Traditional and a Roth IRA?
Generally yes, as long as your combined contributions stay within the annual limit and you meet the eligibility rules for each type. Many savers split deliberately, because having both kinds of balance gives future flexibility over which account to draw from in a given retirement year.
Does the comparison account for being forced to take money out later?
No. Required distributions from Traditional accounts in later life, and their absence for the original owner of a Roth IRA, are not modeled here. That difference can matter a great deal in your late seventies and beyond, beyond what a simple bracket comparison at retirement suggests.
Formula-Based Calculator · By QalcTools Editorial Team. Formulas tested against independent reference values · Content reviewed November 2026 by the QalcTools Editorial Team.
Methodology note: Tax arbitrage mathematical model accounting for opportunity cost of tax deductions.
Related calculators
Category: Investments & Retirement Calculators
About this calculator
Traditional or Roth is not a question about which account grows faster — invested the same way, both grow identically. It is a question about when you pay tax. A Traditional IRA shelters money now and taxes it on the way out; a Roth IRA taxes money now and shelters it on the way out. This calculator runs the same annual contribution through both accounts over your horizon, using your tax rate today against the rate you expect in retirement, and — importantly — it also invests the Traditional route’s upfront tax saving in a taxable side account, so the comparison is honest.
How it works
Enter one annual contribution, your current tax rate, the rate you expect in retirement, the years until withdrawal and an expected return. Both accounts compound the contribution stream at the same return. The Roth figure at the end is fully spendable. The Traditional figure is reduced by retirement tax on the whole balance, then credited with the future value of investing each year’s upfront tax saving — the contribution times your current rate — in a taxable account with a modest tax drag applied. Whichever leaves more spendable money wins, and the page states the margin and the reason in plain terms.
The formula, explained
Future value of contributions = C × ((1 + r)^y − 1) ÷ r; Traditional net = Gross × (1 − Tax in retirement) + (C × Tax today) × FV factor × 0.925; Roth net = Gross
- C — The same annual contribution run through both accounts ($/year)
- r — Expected annual return, identical for both accounts in this comparison (decimal/year)
- y — Years the contributions compound before withdrawal (years)
- 0.925 — The engine’s after-tax drag factor on the reinvested Traditional tax saving: the savings stream’s future value is reduced by 7.5% (factor)
The engine floors the contribution at zero, clamps the horizon between 1 and 100 years and the return between 0 and 100 percent. It builds one future-value factor for the contribution stream — the annuity factor at the entered return, or simply the year count when the return is 0 — and applies it to both accounts. Traditional tax at withdrawal is the gross balance times the retirement rate. The reinvested saving is the annual contribution times the current rate, grown by the same factor, then multiplied by 0.925 to reflect tax drag in a taxable account. If the two net figures land within $50 of each other the verdict is a tie. All money figures are rounded to cents.
Inputs and variables
| Variable | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Contribution | The amount contributed each year, identical for both accounts so the tax treatment is the only difference. The engine projects whatever you enter, so check it against the current IRA limit for your age. | $7,000 per year |
| Current Tax Rate (%) | Your marginal tax rate today. It sets both the value of the Traditional deduction each year and the size of the tax saving available to reinvest. | 24% |
| Retirement Tax Rate (%) | The marginal rate you expect to pay when Traditional withdrawals are taxed. This single assumption usually decides the contest, so test more than one value. | 22% |
| Years to Grow | The compounding horizon, set on the page as retirement age minus current age. Longer horizons enlarge both balances equally and widen the dollar effect of any rate difference. | 25 years |
| Expected Return (%) | The annual return applied to both accounts and to the reinvested tax savings. Because it is the same on both sides, it scales the result without favoring either account. | 7.0% per year |
Worked example
A saver contributes $7,000 a year for 25 years at a 7 percent return, paying 24 percent tax today and expecting 22 percent in retirement.
- Annual contribution: $7,000 for 25 years
- Expected return: 7.0% per year
- Tax rate today: 24%
- Tax rate in retirement: 22%
- Total contributed: $7,000 × 25 = $175,000 into either account. The future-value factor at 7% over 25 years is about 63.249.
- Gross balance in both accounts: $7,000 × 63.249 = $442,743. For the Roth, that whole amount is spendable.
- Traditional tax at withdrawal: $442,743 × 22% = $97,404, leaving $345,340 from the account itself.
- Reinvested tax saving: each year’s $7,000 × 24% = $1,680 saving grows by the same factor and is reduced by the 7.5% drag, adding $98,289.
- Traditional net: $345,340 + $98,289 = $443,629 — ahead of the Roth by $885.
Traditional net spendable value of $443,629 versus $442,743 for the Roth — a Traditional advantage of $885 over 25 years, with $97,404 of tax due on the Traditional balance at withdrawal.
A two-point drop in tax rates produces only a small win, and only because the upfront saving is actually invested — leave that saving in a checking account and the Roth wins instead. The lesson cuts both ways: if your retirement rate turns out equal to or higher than today’s, the same page flips its verdict to the Roth, and the margin grows with the rate gap. Because nobody knows future tax law or their future bracket precisely, many savers split contributions between the two account types as a hedge, and use this page to see which side their own best guess favors.
Understanding your results
The Traditional total has two parts, and both deserve scrutiny. The account itself is worth less than the Roth after withdrawal tax — $345,340 against $442,743 in the example — and only the reinvested tax saving carries it ahead. That makes the verdict depend on behavior, not just brackets: the saving has to be invested every year, for 25 years, for the modeled result to appear. The page’s explanation line restates the winning logic in terms of your two rates, which is the part to test — rerun it with a retirement rate two points higher and watch the recommendation reverse.
Note what the comparison holds equal on purpose: the same gross contribution and the same return on both sides. That isolates the tax question, but it hides a real-world asymmetry — because a Roth contribution is made with after-tax money, contributing the legal maximum shelters more effective wealth in a Roth than in a Traditional account. If you contribute at the limit rather than a fixed affordable amount, that difference matters and is worth weighing alongside the figures here.
Assumptions and limitations
Both tax rates and the investment return are held constant across the whole horizon, while real brackets change with income, filing status and tax law, and returns arrive unevenly. The engine projects any contribution you type without applying IRA contribution limits, income eligibility rules for deducting Traditional contributions or contributing to a Roth, or required distribution rules that later force Traditional money out. The reinvested tax saving is modeled with a single flat drag factor rather than an actual taxable account’s yearly taxes, dividends and capital gains treatment, and state taxes are ignored throughout. Use the verdict as a structured way to compare your own rate guesses, not as a filing recommendation.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Comparing gross balances instead of spendable money. Both accounts show $442,743 before tax in the example, yet they are not equal: the Traditional balance carries a $97,404 tax bill. Only the after-tax figures can be compared fairly.
- Taking the Traditional deduction and spending the saving. The Traditional win in this model depends on investing the yearly tax saving. Spend it, and the Traditional route ends with only its after-tax balance — behind the Roth.
- Using your average tax rate instead of your marginal rate. A deduction saves tax at your top marginal rate, and withdrawals are taxed as they stack on other income. Entering an average rate understates the value of the deduction today.
- Treating today’s bracket as your retirement bracket. Retirement income often comes from several sources that fill brackets gradually. Test a lower and a higher retirement rate and see how much of the verdict is assumption rather than arithmetic.
- Entering a contribution above the legal limit. The engine does not trim entries to the IRA limit for your age. Projecting an amount you cannot actually contribute produces a precise answer to an impossible plan.